Beyond Wittgenstein's Poker: New Light on Popper and by Peter Munz

Posted by

By Peter Munz

Karl Popper and Ludwig Wittgenstein have been of the best philosophers of the 20 th century. The account in their one and merely assembly at Cambridge in 1946 has turn into mythical for the competitive confrontation among the 2 males. Peter Munz, an eye fixed witness to the nice dispute, is the single individual on the earth to were a pupil of either Popper and Wittgenstein. the following he describes their philosophical dating as he skilled it. Munz argues that the later Wittgenstein and Popper needs to be obvious as complementing each other. Popper believed that after fact is found which means will look after itself. despite the fact that, given that, in Popper's view, we will be able to by no means be certain a basic proposition, we will by no means make sure of its fact. There needs to for that reason be a fashion of knowing what it potential even if we can't determine of its fact. The post-Tractatus Wittgenstein allows us to determine how propositions are significant whether we will make certain their fact and hence fills a spot in Popper's philosophy. whilst, Popper was once in a position to make up a deficiency in Wittgenstein's later philosophy. whereas Wittgenstein had had it that significant propositions could be generated in any social order, Popper confirmed that if propositions are to be precise in addition to have which means, the socio-political order within which they're recommend, needs to be unfastened and open. Popper and Wittgenstein have been barking up a similar tree. although they'd a lot to benefit from one another, their personalities stood within the manner. Munz imaginatively reconstructs a discussion to teach how the dialog should have long gone on that recognized night on the ethical Sciences membership in Cambridge in 1946 after which units out intimately the philosophy that might consequence from a synthesis of those nice males.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Wittgenstein's Poker: New Light on Popper and Wittgenstein PDF

Best philosophy books

Ontological Relativity & Other Essays

This quantity contains the 1st of the loo Dewey Lectures brought less than the auspices of Columbia University's Philosophy division in addition to different essays via the writer. meant to elucidate the which means of the philosophical doctrines propounded via W. V. Quine in observe and gadgets, the essays incorporated herein are in detail comparable and obstacle themselves with 3 philosophical preoccupations: the character of that means, the that means of lifestyles and the character of average knowledge.

The World of Thought in Ancient China (Reprint Edition)

The ebook is a lucid, actual, agreeably written and accomplished survey, in response to an extended familiarity with the total of the literature of chinese language faculties of idea right down to the second one century BC, and its nice power is its variety of comparisons with different traditions. chinese language idea hasn't ever ahead of been reflected with rather this breadth of imaginative and prescient.

Il destino della tecnica (BUR Saggi)

Lo scopo distintivo della tradizione occidentale è quello di plasmare il mondo a sua immagine, e lo strumento principe in step with ottenere questo risultato è l. a. tecnica. Le singole forze in conflitto fra loro all’interno di questa tradizione – il cristianesimo, l’umanesimo, l’illuminismo, il sapere filosofico, il capitalismo, los angeles democrazia, il comunismo, il pensiero scientifico – si sono servite e si servono della tecnica in line with a ways prevalere i propri scopi su quelli antagonisti.

The Truth That Frees (Aquinas Lecture 21)

Booklet via Smith, Gerard

Additional resources for Beyond Wittgenstein's Poker: New Light on Popper and Wittgenstein

Example text

By situational analysis. he meant well nigh the opposite - that is, that before we act, we survey a situation and analyse which course of action is logically conducive to the end we have in mind. -‘3There are many possibilities, but proper analysis will show that there is only one likely way. This indicates that wefirst observe the possibilities. and then decide which one we should opt for. Hence Popper referred to such a response to a situation as a ‘rational’ response. This kind of analysis which preceded action and behaviour is in clear contradiction to Popper’s own Darwinian recommendation that, since we cannot stand still and observe.

Dobzhansky, ‘Chance and Creativity in Evolution’, in F. J. Ayala and T. Dobzhansky eds, Studies in the Philosophy of Biology, London, Macmillan, 1974. -P. Changeux, Neuronal Man, New York, Oxford University Press, pp. 279-81; cp. Peter Munz, Philosophical Darwinism, London, Routledge, 1993, pp. l45f. 20 J. D. Watson, TheDouble Helix, Harmondsworth, Penguin, 1970. 15 21 Quoted in Guardian Weekly,18 July to 24 July 2002, p. 18 by Vanessa Thorpe, reviewing Brenda Maddox, Rosalind Franklin, London, HarperCollins.

In this frame of mind, I heard that Karl Popper, the Viennese lecturer in philosophy at Canterbury College of the University of New Zealand, in which I had been enrolled as an undergraduate, had been attacking Plato as a precursor of fascism and as one of the deepest roots of all the evil which was threatening the fi'ee world in the middle of the 20th century. This charge seemed to me so wrong-headed that it made me write an article for the local student magazine in which I explained that Plato ought not to be blamed because he had found the ultimate standard of justice.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.21 of 5 – based on 15 votes